JAPAN ATOMIC INDUSTRIAL FORUM, INC.

for Japanese

ATOMS in JAPAN

9 November, 2017

UNSCEAR White Paper Reiterates Findings that Fukushima Risks Are Low

On October 27, Secretary Malcolm Crick of the United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation (UNSCEAR) paid a courtesy visit to Japanese Parliamentary Vice-Minister for Foreign Affairs Manabu Horii, personally delivering his organization's 2017 white paper on the health risks stemming from radiation exposure due to the nuclear accident following the giant March 2011 earthquake and tsunami. The report was a follow-up to a similar report released in 2013, describing subsequent developments.

Katsurao Village in October 2017

Commenting on the 2013 UNSCEAR report and follow-up activities, the vice-minister said that he valued them as neutral scientific evaluations by a UN organization. Two days later, on October 29, presentations were staged on both the 2013 report and the white paper at Iwaki City in Fukushima Prefecture.

Published by UNSCEAR in April 2014, the 2013 report stated that there was no need in Fukushima to expect significant occurrences of radiation-induced thyroid cancer, as had been observed in the wake of the Chernobyl nuclear accident. It also predicted that there would not be any increased incidence of breast cancer, childhood leukemia and other types of cancer in children to the identification level, and that the most serious and noticeable effects of the accident in the short term would be on mental health and social well-being. UNSCEAR has carried out follow-up activities since it released the 2013 report.

In its recent white paper, UNSCEAR identified further information available through the end of 2016, and systematically determined its effects on the 2013 report. It concluded that no such information substantially affects the main findings of the 2013 report or challenges its major assumptions; rather, much of the new information confirmed those assumptions and findings.

Based on its reviews, UNSCEAR found no need, as of now, to make changes to the evaluations and conclusions of the 2013 report. Regarding several documents and literature, however, it said that more certain evidence must still be obtained through further analyses and additional studies.

Referring to a paper, released in 2016, claiming that crisis rates for thyroid cancer among minors (aged seventeen or less) were twenty to fifty times higher in Fukushima than the Japanese national average, the UNSCEAR white paper pointed out serious flaws, citing excessive bias in its planning and methodology, including insufficient consideration given to the effects of using highly-sensitive ultrasonic inspection devices.

It also noted overdiagnosis from highly-sensitive thyroid examinations using ultrasonic waves, as well as concerns about active treatment of minor thyroid cancers, adding that thyroid screening was a complicated issue. It also mentioned factors going beyond genuine scientific questions when determining the scope, nature and continuation of screening after the Fukushima Daiichi accident: namely, matters related to socioeconomic issues, public health, law, morality and human rights.

Elsewhere, at the 28th meeting of the study committee for the Fukushima Health Management Survey held on October 23, Hajime Suzuki, clinic director at the International University of Health and Welfare, reported that the average thyroid equivalent dose from external and internal radiation exposure for one-year-old infants in the prefecture had been reevaluated to incorporate new information. He said that results were obtained of less than 40mSv in all areas, which is within seven to sixty-nine percent, as stated in the UNSCEAR 2013 report.

The committee will continue to work to reduce uncertainties in data, and will reevaluate doses again in FY18 (April 2018 to March 2019).

Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

SNS facebooktwitter

NPPs Map

Video

Grossi on Fukushima: Marking a Decade Since the Accident

10 March, 2021
Grossi on Fukushima: Marking a Decade Since the Accident04:11

Recent News

15 October, 2021
LDP Adds SMR Development and Nuclear Fusion to NPP Restarts in Its Policy Manifesto
7 October, 2021
Kishida Administration Inaugurated, with New METI Minister Hagiuda Holding Press Conference on Taking Office
6 October, 2021
IAEA Holds 65th General Conference in Vienna, with Japanese Minister of State for Science and Technology Delivering Statement in the General Debate
30 September, 2021
JAEC Releases 2020 White Paper on Nuclear Energy
17 September, 2021
NRA Permits Shimane-2 under New Regulatory Standards
14 September, 2021
IAEA Deputy Director General Evrard Visits Japan in Advance of Safety Review of ALPS-treated Water
1 September, 2021
Evaluation Report Issued by IAEA’s Review Mission to Fukushima Daiichi: First Visit since 2018
24 August, 2021
METI and IAEA Agree on Further Review Missions to Fukushima Daiichi
4 August, 2021
JAEA Restarts High-Temperature Engineering Test Reactor “HTTR”
2 August, 2021
Information about Fukushima Daiichi NPS Water Treatment
28 July, 2021
METI’s Committee Shows Rough Draft of Next Strategic Energy Plan
2 July, 2021
Mihama-3 Restarted After Decade-long Hiatus: First Restart in Japan of a Reactor Operating Beyond 40 Years
28 June, 2021
Mihama-3 Restarts after Decade-long Hiatus
25 June, 2021
New Canada-Japan Partnership Supports Greater Collaboration to Meet Climate Change Objectives and Net-zero Goals
24 June, 2021
METI Issues New Green Growth Strategy Through Achieving Carbon Neutrality
16 June, 2021
ANRE Sticks to “S+3E”
16 June, 2021
Japanese Cabinet Approves Environmental White Paper 2021
16 June, 2021
LDP Parliamentary Association to Reconfirm Position on Utilization of Nuclear Power
16 June, 2021
Fukui Governor Concerned about Deletion of Reference to “Maximum Utilization” of Nuclear Power
14 June, 2021
Working Group on Offshore Release of Treated Water Meets in Miyagi
▲TOP