for Japanese


25 January, 2016

Nuclear Liability Committee Discusses Scope of Responsibility and Operator Foreseeability

On January 20, a meeting was held in Tokyo of the special committee on the nuclear damage compensation system under the Japan Atomic Energy Commission (JAEC). The members discussed such matters as strict legal liability and the channeling of liability, along with the scope of responsibility and financial security, as parts of an ideal system of nuclear damage compensation.

They continued discussions of the previous meeting concerning the division of responsibility between the public and private sectors. Professor Shigeru Takahashi of the Hitotsubashi University Graduate School of Law said that it was unreasonable to incorporate such a division in general laws, as the locus of responsibility depends on the facts and circumstances of each particular incident. He added that it was thus more appropriate for the government to determine the responsibility case by case, and also said that it was important for the system to enable relief to be provided to disaster victims evenly.

Another committee member, Toshihiko Baba of the Central Union of Agricultural Cooperatives, said that the government should come to the forefront and verify a mechanism to respond to victims’ needs promptly, citing the inordinate time taken for people to get compensated after the March 2011 accident at the Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Plants. The reason, he said, was that it is not always clear who is responsible when an accident occurs.

As for strict legal liability and the channeling of liability, committee members mostly thought it appropriate not to apply the Product Liability Law. As for the scope of liability, Executive Director Yuka Matayoshi of Morgan Stanley MUFG Securities Co., Ltd. said that it was important to discuss such issues considering changes stemming from the deregulation of Japan’s retail electricity market, as well as looking at overseas examples. She then cautioned that while everyone was mindful of the importance of responding flexibly, it could also make things less foreseeable for nuclear operators.

Regarding concerns that limited liability may lead to a safety “moral hazard”—referring to people’s tendency to loosen vigilance in such situations—Professor Hiroshi Ohashi of the Graduate School of Economics at the University of Tokyo pointed out that there was already an “institutional brake” in the case of nuclear power: namely, the process involving regulatory standards and approvals from municipalities.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

SNS facebooktwitter

NPPs Map


Grossi on Fukushima: Marking a Decade Since the Accident

10 March, 2021
Grossi on Fukushima: Marking a Decade Since the Accident04:11

Recent News

17 September, 2021
NRA Permits Shimane-2 under New Regulatory Standards
14 September, 2021
IAEA Deputy Director General Evrard Visits Japan in Advance of Safety Review of ALPS-treated Water
1 September, 2021
Evaluation Report Issued by IAEA’s Review Mission to Fukushima Daiichi: First Visit since 2018
24 August, 2021
METI and IAEA Agree on Further Review Missions to Fukushima Daiichi
4 August, 2021
JAEA Restarts High-Temperature Engineering Test Reactor “HTTR”
2 August, 2021
Information about Fukushima Daiichi NPS Water Treatment
28 July, 2021
METI’s Committee Shows Rough Draft of Next Strategic Energy Plan
2 July, 2021
Mihama-3 Restarted After Decade-long Hiatus: First Restart in Japan of a Reactor Operating Beyond 40 Years
28 June, 2021
Mihama-3 Restarts after Decade-long Hiatus
25 June, 2021
New Canada-Japan Partnership Supports Greater Collaboration to Meet Climate Change Objectives and Net-zero Goals
24 June, 2021
METI Issues New Green Growth Strategy Through Achieving Carbon Neutrality
16 June, 2021
ANRE Sticks to “S+3E”
16 June, 2021
Japanese Cabinet Approves Environmental White Paper 2021
16 June, 2021
LDP Parliamentary Association to Reconfirm Position on Utilization of Nuclear Power
16 June, 2021
Fukui Governor Concerned about Deletion of Reference to “Maximum Utilization” of Nuclear Power
14 June, 2021
Working Group on Offshore Release of Treated Water Meets in Miyagi
14 June, 2021
NRA Considers Policy on Treating Slurry from ALPS, with Local Understanding Essential
11 June, 2021
Japanese Cabinet Approves Energy White Paper 2021
11 June, 2021
Government Omits Description of “Maximum Utilization” of Nuclear Power
9 June, 2021
MNF Hopes to Resume Fuel Production as Early as November